Blockchain & Cryptocurrency
Blockchain & Cryptocurrency
Assessment of blockchain business models / whitepaper reviews
We assess your blockchain business model and operational practices, to consider the extent that your token-related activities invoke Canadian federal and Ontario laws.
For example, we regularly consider how your particular token-related activities invoke the laws of:
securities (e.g. ICOs / ITOs, SAFT issues, OSC LaunchPad representation, "securities" trigger, dealer exemptions, prospectus exemptions/private placements, secondary market issues, etc.);
cryptocurrency contracting (e.g. Currency Act, Statute of Frauds, Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, etc.);
anti-money laundering (AML);
financial institution issues (e.g. Bank Act and Trust and Loan Companies Act);
other fiduciary issues (e.g. trustee/bailee issues, sale of goods, consumer protection, payday loans, general negligence);
IT contracts with third-party tech vendors;
mining coalition agreements;
data privacy in Canada;
AI & algorithmic governance in smart contracts;
corporate veil issues (e.g. regarding operations of a foreign wholly owned subsidiary);
public international law;
private international law (i.e. conflicts of laws);
division of legislative powers;
Customs Act issues (for import/export of tokens as non-money goods); and
export controls (i.e. "token coin" as controlled outside "Systems, Equipment and Components", international trade models).
As your blockchain lawyers, we also assess whether your smart contract mechanisms are likely to be considered a service, rather than a security or commodity, for tax and fiduciary purposes. (See Part 1 of our "Crypto-Tax Primer" blog series.)
We also work with counsel in other jurisdictions, if requested, for the purposes of cross-jurisdictional compliance.
ICOs / ITOs and digital asset dealing / advising
There is increasing regulatory scrutiny on fundraising through the sale of digital assets, and dealing or advising with respect to digital assets.
This space in Canada is being developed primarily by the Canadian Securities Administrators, individual Canadian regulators, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, and judicial precedent. We continually monitor the regulatory landscape for changes.
As your blockchain lawyers, we are equipped to assess your business model—as well as the nature, features, and use of your token—to assess the probability that your blockchain activities will engage securities laws in Ontario and Canadian passport jurisdictions. (See our blog posts, "Security Tokens – A Developing Concept", and "The Law of ICOs/ITOs: Simplified".)
In the event that securities laws are engaged, we will:
consider prospectus and registration exemptions, as appropriate (see our blog posts, "Prospectus Exemption Options for Blockchain Businesses", and "Securities Registration Requirements for Blockchain Businesses"); and
consider any regulatory and/or criminal liability resulting from over-the-counter trades, as appropriate (see our blog post, "Foreign Issued Tokens Traded Over-the-Counter in Canada").
Most blockchain businesses intend to operate across jurisdictions. As your blockchain lawyers, we can work with counsel in other jurisdictions to maximize the chance of compliance from wherever your platform can be accessed.
We also consider more complicated token-sale arrangements. For example: a private placement under a Simple Agreement for Future Tokens ("SAFT") prior to platform/MVP development, followed by a public token offering and distribution after operations have begun. In such an arrangement, we work to limit risk that investors under the SAFT will compete with the subsequent public token distribution.
Issues regarding privacy, trust, and duties among blockchain users and third parties
Data privacy issues are invoked by "closed" or "permissioned" blockchains, intending to limit read/write access to particular users. While the immutability of the records may be near impossible to hack, maliciously obtained read/write access to the blockchain through a platform's user account, or through the backdoor to the platform, can still cause unanticipated damage.
As your blockchain lawyers, we can deal with these issues:
before they arise, in an opinion or through contracts; and
after they arise, through arbitration or litigation.
Moreover, your business may want to relax the immutable nature of your distributed ledger in certain cases—for example, in the event of a hack. It may also need to expand or restrict its operations in foreign jurisdictions from time to time, based on regulatory developments in those jurisdictions.
As your blockchain lawyers, we can:
work to enforce such a document in disputes between the platform and its users, or between users.
Agreements re smart contract intentions and mechanisms
Smart contracts are executable scripts, not legal contracts.
This remains true irrespective of whether your blockchain:
operates under a native platform run by a traditional corporation;
has no native platform, and operates through a Turing-complete decentralized autonomous organization ("DAO"); or
operates completely open-source with all operations governed through user consensus.
As your blockchain lawyers, we draft and negotiate legal contracts that capture the intention of the code in your smart contract. Such contracts are meant to:
set a jurisdiction's law as governing the contract;
capture transaction mechanisms;
address algorithmic governance issues;
disclaim or plan liability issues arising from bugs resulting in damages;
establish a process for agreed-upon revisions to the code, or early termination of the smart contract; and
establish a dispute resolution mechanism, inclusive of establishing a chosen forum for resolving disputes.
Due diligence or vetting smart contract development and execution
As your blockchain lawyers, we work with qualified third parties to vet a given smart contract. This is done to maximize the alignment between the parties' intentions, and the code operating pursuant to those intentions.
This service is offered in conjunction with drafting/negotiating the legal contract which underpins your smart contract. Whether your business is responsible for smart contract development, and whether such development has completed or has yet to occur, will determine if this service is performed before or after the drafting/negotiation phase.
We can also represent you in a dispute arising from the alleged failure of a smart contract, whether or not a legally enforceable contract exists.
Legal aspects of proof-of-work and proof-of-stake blockchain models
The incentives and rewards are quite different between these two systems of transaction validation. In proof of work ("PoW"), miners get block rewards in the form of new coins. In contrast, proof of stake ("PoS") does not involve the creation of new coins, and instead rewards forgers with transaction fees.
Setting expectations among users and miners/forgers is crucial to ensuring all parties agree to the rewards associated with the underlying operations of your blockchain. Moreover, changing a blockchain's transaction validation system between PoW to PoS, or vice-versa, takes careful planning.
As your blockchain lawyers, we draft contracts and blockchain governance documents between affected parties, to ensure smooth operations associated with PoW and PoS models, and any transition between the two.
Disclaimers re blockchain use, smart contracts and blockchain forking
There are risks to any blockchain business that encourages user activity, facilitates third party integrations, and implements algorithmic determinations. Such risks increase substantially when the business makes platform changes, or permits vendor integrations, that affect users' stakes. There are additional obligations where business operations result in a trust for the benefit of users. As your blockchain lawyers, we work to limit your exposure to such risks in advance.
Agreements among or with full nodes
Blockchains, due to their decentralized nature, require nodes as network support pillars. Any independent party acting as a node has an interest in performing that function. That interest usually involves remuneration in some form. Node-platform and/or node-node contracts are recommended, particularly where such remuneration arises independently of blockchain operations (i.e. non-mining operations). As your blockchain lawyers, we can draft and negotiation such contracts.
Contracts denominated in cryptocurrency
Canadian cases indicate that cryptocurrency could be "money". U.S. cases indicate that cryptocurrency definitely is "money". This presents a problem under Canadian law, because contracts denominated in cryptocurrency are not legal if the cryptocurrency is treated as "money". (See our article, "Cryptocurrency Can’t Be “Money” in Canadian Commercial Law".)
Treating cryptocurrency as a commodity does not entirely fix the problem, because such treatment may have negative GST-HST implications. (See our blog post, "The CRA’s Present Position on Crypto-Tax.)
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will work toward achieving contract mechanisms and results that are "normal", or at least predictable. We approach cryptocurrency contracts with an appreciation of:
the relevant "money" cases in Canada and the U.S; and
drafting subtleties required to navigate the above "money" issues.
Virtual currency regulations, including operation as a "money services business"
Canadian federal virtual currency regulations are in force as of July 10, 2019. Additional regulations with respect to virtual currency dealers will come into force on June 1, 2020.
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will assess the probability of your business being a money services business as a result of "dealing in virtual currencies", and develop a customized set of compliance strategies and policies. (See our blog post, "Virtual Currency Regulations in Canada: Will Your Blockchain Business Be Affected?")
Anti-money-laundering (AML) issues
We assess compliance with regulatory requirements for money services businesses that deal in virtual currencies, under the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act and its Regulations.
As of July 10, 2019, certain reporting entities now have additional obligations with respect to virtual currencies. Additional regulations with respect to virtual currency dealers will come into force on June 1, 2020.
As your blockchain and cryptocurrency lawyers, we will develop a customized set of compliance strategies and policies that consider your AML position today, and when the new regulations come into force.
Know Your Client (KYC) issues
Canadian regulations, which address KYC requirements for persons and businesses "dealing in virtual currencies", have been released in draft.
These draft regulations address the issue of anonymous crypto transfers facilitating money laundering and terrorist financing. (See our blog post, "Crypto-KYC in Canada".)
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will:
assess your risk associated with current and foreseeable KYC issues;
assess your compliance with current and foreseeable regulations; and
develop a customized set of compliance strategies and policies.
Crypto trading and related tax issues
The CRA does not recognize cryptocurrency as national legal tender. It has stated that GST-HST is applicable to trades for goods or services depending on fair market value in CAD.
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will assess how this position affects to your particular business model and transactions pursuant to the Income Tax Act and the Excise Tax Act. (See our "Crypto-Tax Primer" blog series.)
For cryptocurrency exchanges and wallets—we will assess whether your users' activities invoke GST-HST tax liability for the following types of transactions performed between initial account funding and interim/final withdrawals:
Crypto value manipulation issues
We are equipped to assess whether the foreseeable use of your token may attract exposure under the fraud and market manipulation provisions of Ontario's Security Act and the Criminal Code. (See our article, "Foreign Issued Tokens Traded Over-the-Counter in Canada".)
As your blockchain and cryptocurrency lawyers, we will provide feedback on your business plan and token mechanisms to limit the risk of attracting such exposure.
Financial institution regulations and fiduciary obligations
Depending on the business model, a cryptocurrency exchange or wallet business could in substance be engaged in "banking", and be required to continue operations under the Bank Act. Alternatively, continuation under the Trust and Loan Companies Act may be required. (See our article, "Financial Institution Regulations".)
At the very least, there may be fiduciary obligations owed, including those of an administrative nature to charge and remit GST-HST for all on-platform trades. (See our blog, "Crypto-Exchange/Wallet Tax Issues".)
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will consider your business operations to develop a strategy for minimizing the risk and/or impact of such obligations.
Cryptocurrency monetary instruments
It is not presently possible under Canadian law to create an "inland" cryptocurrency monetary instrument. However, it may be possible to create a "foreign" cryptocurrency monetary instrument.
The creation and use of such an instrument would require an appreciation of the Canadian cases that distinguish legal tender from monetary instruments. (See our article, "Cryptocurrency and Monetary Instruments".)
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will draft a legal plan that most closely aligns your cryptocurrency monetary product with its intended objectives.
Payment system issues
The designation of a payment system in the public interest is at the option of the Minister of Finance. On this basis, it is entirely foreseeable that cryptocurrency payment mechanisms will eventually be subject to regulation under the Canadian Payments Act.
As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will assess what this could mean for your business, and whether an application for membership in the Canadian Payments Association would be advantageous. (See our article, "Financial Institution Regulations".)
Mining coalition agreements
Mining coalitions share computing resources, real estate, profits, losses, tax benefits, and tax liabilities. Decisions and dispute outcomes largely rely on agreements establishing coalition parties' rights and liabilities. As your cryptocurrency lawyers, we will represent your coalition, or you as an individual coalition party, in negotiation or in dispute.